March 15, 2013
The challenges of the coal-mining life from a working canary's point of view. Brave little Bitty is an earnest and dedicated yellow finch slaving away in a West Virginia coal mine. But the increasingly dangerous conditions in the mine soon inspire him to finesse an escape from Coalbank Hollow, hoping to meet with legislators in Charleston to better the miners' lot in life. His ambition is nothing less than to change the entire dynamics of the mining world. Bitty's sense of social justice eventually collides head-on with the future, as mine owners contemplate replacing gas-identifying canaries with "new-fangled machinery" like the "Whatchamacallit." In her author's note to this debut novel, picture-book writer Rosenberg reveals that her father's grandfather was once the owner of a coal mine (of the real Coalbank Hollow), albeit a more compassionate one than those portrayed in the book. Illuminating this complex world through the eyes of the canaries that are employed to protect workers is a charming and inventive concept. Happily, Bitty and his mates are often sweet and funny, as their lives inevitably intertwine with the human miners. But the middle of the story gets a tad mired in didactic details, slow pacing and ho-hum dialogue. Endearing and original, if a bit long and drawn-out. (Historical fantasy. 8-12)
COPYRIGHT(2013) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
May 1, 2013
Gr 4-6-Bitty, a canary, tells the story of life in a small coal-mining town in West Virginia during the Depression. Miners carried the birds into the mines to detect the presence of toxic gases long before mechanical devices were invented and made affordable. Bitty lives in the big house, a large aviary in the bedroom of Jamie, a boy who rents out the canaries to the miners each day. The story does a nice job of describing the dangers and safety issues involved in the early mining industry. Bitty takes it upon himself to escape the aviary and travel to the state capital to try and lobby for safer working conditions and freedom for the birds. He meets a variety of animals and people along the way and touches on some historical events such as the construction of the state capitol dome. But historical references are fleeting, and the abundance of extraneous characters bogs down the story line. The mere mention of activist Mother Jones, who died before this story took place, and real names of state legislators and inventors do little to advance the plot. A Depression-era tale with talking animals gives this story a touch of whimsy, though, and Bitty's persistence will eventually reward those who make it to the conclusion.-Cheryl Ashton, Amherst Public Library, OH
Copyright 2013 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
January 1, 2014
When Bitty, a brave little miner canary in depression-era West Virginia, learns about a mechanical way to detect gas in the coal mines and save lives of miners and their canaries, he flies to the state capital to make his case. Interesting historical content and likable talking-animal characters are hampered by a slow-moving midsection, coincidences, and lengthy side stories.
(Copyright 2014 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)